share on
Here's how to avoid common mentoring pitfalls such as a lack of commitment, disengagement, and mentees feeling like their needs aren't being met.
The recent International Mentoring Day (yes, it's an actual day!), which falls on 17 January ever year, got the HRO team reflecting on what we believe makes mentoring an essential tool at the workplace. It’s not just employees who benefit — leaders and organisations gain just as much from a strong mentoring culture.
We have had the opportunity to learn a lot about mentoring through our various interviews with leaders in the region, and even our conferences — the different forms of mentoring organisations are exploring, challenges leaders have faced implementing a mentorship programme, and our personal favourite — ways in which leaders have grown from partaking in such programmes.
Why mentoring is so important
What makes mentoring so effective is that it extends beyond skill development, playing a crucial role in talent retention, grooming a leadership pipeline, and increasing employee satisfaction. It can help bridge knowledge gaps, foster a collaborative work culture, and equip employees with the confidence to take on new challenges.
In fact, studies show that employees with access to mentorship are more engaged and less likely to leave their organisation.
However, like any professional relationship, mentoring comes with its challenges. Here are five common mistakes that can hamper the experience:
- Failure to set clear goals: Without clear objectives, mentoring can become directionless, leading to a lack of progress and disengagement.
- Lack of commitment: Mentors who fail to dedicate time and effort can leave mentees feeling neglected and disengaged.
- One-size-fits-all approach: Failing to acknowledge that every mentee is different, and in turn failing to personalise your approach to guidance can have a negative impact on the process, if mentees don't feel like their needs are being met.
- Unreceptiveness to feedback: A strong mentoring relationship thrives on open dialogue. If mentors and mentees ignore each other’s input, growth and learning are stifled.
With these pitfalls in mind, let’s have a look at the key traits of an effective mentor, and 10 practical tips to ensure mentoring delivers meaningful impact.
Websites referenced have been hyperlinked out accordingly.
What makes a great mentor?
A great mentor is more than just an experienced professional — they are a guide, coach, and role model. Some key traits of effective mentors include:
- Active listening: A good mentor listens carefully, allowing mentees to express concerns and aspirations.
- Empathy and patience: Understanding different perspectives and giving mentees the space to grow is essential.
- Honest and constructive feedback: Effective mentors provide actionable advice and help mentees navigate challenges.
- Commitment and availability: Mentors must dedicate time to their mentees and be approachable when guidance is needed.
- Encouraging independence: Rather than offering direct solutions, great mentors empower mentees to think critically and make informed decisions.
With the above in mind, here are some ways you can get started on a structured, well-meaning mentorship programme:
First things first, set clear objectives and expectations. A successful mentoring relationship starts with well-defined goals, and both the mentor and mentee should outline what they hope to achieve—whether it’s career progression, leadership development, or skill-building.
Establishing a roadmap from the outset keeps the relationship structured and ensures progress can be measured.
Next, be strategic in how you match mentors and mentees. Finding the right mentor-mentee pair is crucial. Consider aligning individuals based on career aspirations, leadership styles, and personality traits.
To give you a better idea on your pairing, consider conducting internal surveys or leveraging your HR platforms as an aid to map out characteristics, strengths, and more.
Third, be that person (or team) who encourages a two-way learning experience. Mentoring is not a one-sided process. While mentees gain insights from experienced professionals, mentors can also learn from their mentees — whether it’s fresh perspectives, industry trends, or digital skills.
As such, encouraging open dialogue can go a long way in ensuring the relationship remains mutually beneficial.
The fourth thing to do is create a safe and supportive environment. For mentoring to be effective, mentees must feel comfortable discussing challenges, seeking guidance, and receiving feedback.
HR teams should provide guidelines that foster psychological safety, ensuring that mentoring conversations remain confidential and supportive.
Fifth: Provide structured but flexible frameworks. While organic mentoring relationships can be valuable, structured programmes help provide consistency. This is where you can look into implementing milestone check-ins, suggested discussion topics, and training resources.
However, flexibility is key — do be sure to allow mentors and mentees the freedom to tailor their engagements based on evolving needs.
[ALSO READ: How to be a good mentor at work (and the 5 types of mentor personas)]
The sixth tip we have is to integrate mentoring into career development plans. Rather than viewing mentoring as a standalone initiative, organisations should embed it into their broader talent development strategy. Linking mentorship to career progression — such as leadership pathways or succession planning — helps mentees see its long-term value and impact.
Of course, while crafting your strategy, do take into consideration the technology available to aid in mentoring. With remote and hybrid work pretty much a norm in many organisations, having digital mentoring platforms can help bridge any geographical gaps.
Virtual check-ins, online learning resources, and AI-driven matching tools make it easier to connect employees across regions, ensuring accessibility and inclusivity.
Tip number 8: Recognise and reward effective mentoring. Rewards & recognition, as we know, play a big role in boosting morale and engagement. Acknowledging the contributions of mentors can also encourage a culture of knowledge-sharing.
Thus, it would be worth looking into simple yet impactful ways of recognition, such as internal awards, 'shoutouts', or incentives to motivate more employees to take on mentoring roles.
Finally, once everything is in place and running, just like with every talent strategy you've set in place, it would be crucial to measure the impact of your mentoring programme, and gather feedback. Do make it a point to collect feedback from both mentors and mentees to understand challenges, track progress, and refine initiatives.
Metrics such as career advancements, retention rates, and employee satisfaction can provide insights into the programme’s success.
All in all, it's worth noting that mentoring should not be a one-time initiative, but an ongoing practice embedded in the organisation’s culture. It's only with true effort that you will reap the biggest benefit yet: Watching your mentee grow!
share on
